So last night my Dad and I were once again watching Best Thing I Ever Ate, and once again it was WAY past dinnertime so once again we were STARVING as we watched (why we do this to ourselves, I have no idea). The episode theme was 'Served Chilled,' and a recipe came on for Lemon Icebox Pie from a little restaurant called Crystal Grill in Greenwood, Mississippi. People apparently come from all over to get these famous pies, and my Dad and I (both lovers of my grandmothers infamous Lemon Meringue pies) instantly latched on to this recipe and decided to make it the next day. We were missing the oven temperature, so my Dad (always the salesman) called up the Crystal Grill and told them our story. After listening to his accent ("Son, I can tell you're real because you sho' ain't from 'round these parts"), and thanking us for calling (they've had a huge influx of customers and calls since the show), the owner of the place said he would love to share the recipe with us. Not only did he give exact measurements and directions, but he also said to make sure the we put "a cup 'a love in it too" (also on the show the chef says that the way to make lemon icebox pie is to really want some lemon icebox pie). So, today this is what I baked, making sure that I really wanted it (not a hard thing to do- it looks so good!) and adding in my cup of love. The result- a suuuuper creamy lemony tart pie that was delicious! It was amazing chilled, and in the future I think I am going to try this recipe with key lime instead of lemon as well. :) I got the whipped cream recipe online, and in the future I think I will add in at least one more tbsp of sugar since I would have liked it sweeter. But all in all, it was an amazing pie!
Just a note- the recipe calls for leaving the pie in the fridge overnight, but I only left it for 6 hours and it was fine. At any rate, plan on making this WAY ahead of time!!
Ingredients:
1 graham cracker crust (they actually recommended store-bought)
6 egg yolks
1 qt. sweetened condensed milk
1 cup lemon juice
1 pint heavy whipping cream
2 tbsp confectioners sugar
2 tsp vanilla extract
1 lemon (for decoration)
1 cup 'a love :)
Directions:
1. Preheat oven to 325. Place crust on baking sheet.
2. In large bowl, mix egg yolks lightly with whisk until broken and blended. Add in condensed milk and lemon juice, stir with whisk until mixture is smooth and creamy. (A note from me based on past baking experience: make sure not to whisk which would add in air bubbles- this should be dense and thick, not light and airy- for the same reason do no over stir!).
3. Pour mixture into crust, bake for 20 minutes.
4. Refrigerate overnight. (I did this for 7 hours and it turned out fine)
5. Make the whipped cream: Chill the beaters and the bowl in the freezer for at least 10 minutes (this helps the cream solidify). Pour the COLD heavy whipping cream into a large bowl and beat on high. Just before peaks begin to form (the cream will get slightly thicker), add in the sugar and vanilla, 1 tbsp/tsp at a time and beat. Continue beating until it turns into whipped cream, with stiff peaks.
6. Cover the chilled pie in whipped cream, decorate with lemon slices, and serve immediately! :)
.jpg)





