
So first off let me say that this is not the world's best photo of a dish, but- I think it's a testament to how good these shells are because I was so busy eating them that I forgot to take a photo until I only had what was left in the dish in front of me. :) These stuffed shells were created by a friend and I one night when we didn't want to go out to eat but wanted a nice dinner. They are modeled off a white lasagna that is a specialty of her fathers- so much so that the family only eats it once a year on her birthday. The dish can get a little pricey to make with all of the cheeses, but it makes an enormous batch that will last a while. You can play around with the cheeses, depending on your preferences, but make sure you have a good balance of hard and soft cheeses so that they melt easily into a sauce. This recipe is such that you should feel free to play around with both cheeses and measurements, tasting as you go so that things like the sauce thickness (I prefer a thicker sauce), cheese balance (I like a sharper rather than creamier taste), and wine strength (I like a stronger taste) are to your own liking. I should also warn that these shells are time consuming to make as well, so be sure to grab a cooking buddy or start cooking early. As a final warning, this is also one of the most fattening dishes that I make, but it's a total splurge that's worth every bite. Enjoy!
Ingredients:
1 box jumbo pasta shells
1 small container ricotta cheese (you can use low fat)
2 containers freshly grated hard cheeses (I use parmesan and asiago)
2 blocks soft white cheeses (I use fontina and butterkase, or sometimes 2 blocks of fontina), shredded
1 bag fresh spinach (or 1 box of frozen spinach)
1 package sweet italian sausage
2 cloves minced garlic
1 bottle riesling
1 container heavy cream
1/2 tsp. black pepper
Directions:
1. Cook pasta shells as directed on box, drain and set aside.
2. Set half of the hard and soft cheese (not the ricotta) aside for the sauce. Mix remaining cheeses together along with ricotta in large bowl, varying amounts of hard and soft cheeses to your preference, set aside. (Tip: I have learned that the parmesan can overpower this dish, so I always go lighter on this than the other cheeses in both the filling and the sauce)
3. Cook spinach (steamed if fresh, thawed and drained if frozen), set aside in separate bowl.
4. Uncase the sausage and cook in saucepan over medium high heat (do not use oil or cooking spray), crumbling until brown. Add in garlic when sausage is almost brown and stir to combine. Remove from pan and put in bowl with spinach. Set pan aside but do not rinse.
5. Preheat oven to 350.
6. Combine the spinach, sausage, and the cheese mixture (with the ricotta) in bowl. Stuff this mixture into the shells, such that each shell is completely filled to the top. Line the shells in the bottom of a large aluminum pan, or in two rectangular baking pans. Set aside.
7. Reheat the pan used to cook the sausage over medium heat, once heated add in wine (I use about a cup) to deglaze the pan, scraping in all of the bits of sausage and garlic leftover. Add in cream and stir. Slowly add in the remaining cheeses (making sure to taste along the way), stirring until the sauce becomes smooth and all the cheese has melted. Add pepper, and adjust wine/cheeses/thickness to your liking. Pour sauce over stuffed shells, making sure to coat each one if possible.
8. Bake shells, covered with foil, for 15-20 minutes. The cheese in the shells should have melted, and the shells should be nice and hot. Serve with remaining riesling and enjoy! (Note: I usually drink the riesling as I cook, so a second bottle is highly recommended!)
*I also should add that if you have leftovers (which is most likely), always heat in a covered dish so that the shells do not dry out and harden.